Wednesday, 7 December 2016

Modi’s failed demonetization drive is showing

























In less than a month’s time, the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) has been forced to cut the growth forecast by 50 bps from 7.6% to 7.1% for 2017. This has washed off the Government’s claims that demonetization would only have a temporary impact on the economy for one or two quarters. The Commerce Minister was even suggesting that the impact may not be felt beyond the present quarter. 

Coming within a few days of Nikkei PMI contraction to a 3 year low, this does not augur well for the economy or the Government’s claims. This reflects that further pain is in store for the economy on several counts.

The Reserve Bank has noted that the prices of wheat, gram and sugar are firming up. Limping back in the face of four years of droughts, the agricultural sector has been hit hard with the demonetization. A year of good monsoons should have seen food prices drop rather than rise sharply. The exact opposite has happened. Farmers were forced to delay sowing due to non-availability of cash. District Co-operative banks predominant in the rural areas are still not accepting old notes and new notes were not available. Banks were perennially out of cash for the vast majority of population, but had ready availability for certain influential sections.

Secondly, people got a glimpse of what it is like not being able to utilize one’s own money. It was a maze without exit for people with bank accounts. This will definitely have a huge psychological impact and people will think before spending money and may even prefer to save the cash withdrawn. The economy running primarily on consumer demand is likely to be hit further. Corporate demand essentially being non-existent, the economy is likely to take atleast 100-150 bps hit. This does not seem far-fetched given that the RBI was forced to revise its estimate for the entire 2017 within a matter of a month only.

Both the above factors will have a decidedly negative impact on demand and consumption. Infrastructure and B2B companies were anyways not in a great shape. Now B2C companies are likely to see their sales and profitability plummet.


Study in Contrast

Dollar Tree and Tiffany riding high on Trump wave

A previous post had mentioned that some of the stocks to benefit from the new administration would be Dollar General (DG), Dollar Tree (DLTR) and Tiffany (TIF).

Less than a month down the line these stocks have gained an average 15% with DLTR leading the pack at 19% and TIF 14% approx.

It would seem a bit strange that both dollar stores and Tiffany would be gaining at the same time. However, both these classes of companies cater to distinct demographics which will see increased demand in the foreseeable future. Demand for luxury items is sure to increase with investment spending and tax cuts. While the middle class base would also continue to rise seeing increased footfalls in Dollar Tree and Dollar General.























Source: NYSE



Monday, 5 December 2016

Modi’s gamble leaves millions of Indians vulnerable to mobile banking hacks






Indian Prime Minister, Mr. Narendra Modi’s gamble to usher in a new era of banking through smartphones is sure to make hackers sit up and take notice.

A recent instance in Dubai wherein hackers obtained duplicate SIM cards and embezzled Dh 1 million through the smartphone mobile banking app should have been enough to make the Indian authorities stand up and take notice.  However, the Indian authorities seem to be blissfully unaware of the perils of mobile banking apps and are blindly urging Indians to switch to the mobile banking channel en masse.

A recent WSJ report mentions that the situation has turned serious enough for the FBI to start paying attention. Specific apps are being created to target the mobile banking channel. UK’s Three Mobile and Tesco were also targeted by cyber criminals recently. The recent hack of 3.2 million debit cards is still fresh in memory.

Given such a state of affairs, belligerent insistence on using mobile banking channel is sure to have serious repercussions for Indian consumers. In his desperate urge to usher in the digital revolution, Mr. Modi seems to have forgotten that robust cyber security and security laws are the only base upon which such technology can be ushered in and not merely upon empty words.

Saturday, 19 November 2016

Midnight strike at Rural India

























The effects of Mr. Modi's decision to demonetize Rs. 500 and Rs. 1,000 currency notes are slowly creeping in. First and foremost to be affected are the farmers and small traders in rural India. 

A midnight strike at the peak of the sowing season has left them bewildered and helpless. While the people in urban India have access to multiple banks and branches, rural India doesn't have such access. Even the RBI agrees that banking penetration is very poor in the hinterland with most of the banking happening through the unorganized sector. Coupled with the decision to restrict co-operative banks from accepting the old notes, rural India is squeezed from multiple sides.

The urban elite can keep on harping at the "grand gesture" but the sad truth is that rural India has been left to fend for itself. With only 10-15 days to go for the sowing season and with the nearest bank branch miles away, the small Indian farmer has taken the maximum hit from this move. This does not augur well for the Indian economy or even India as a whole. To weed out a few people the entire country has been forced into unnecessary trials and tribulations.

The people of India would have appreciated and welcomed the demonetization move if certain prior steps were taken:

1. Food and drug adulteration
Just ask yourself one question: Are you a 100% sure that the milk you are drinking or the medicines you are taking is genuine? Pretty sure that no one can claim as such. This only reflects the extent of food and drug adulteration existing within the country. Concrete steps and strict punishment should be enforced to ensure that the guilty are not spared. 

2. Target the specific individuals
It is common knowledge and the officials are very well aware where corruption exists. The Slum Rehabilitation Agency in Mumbai is a hotbed of corruption. Everyone is aware of that. Rather than target the specific individuals and government agencies, carpet bombing was resorted to without any specific actions targeted at specific individuals. 

3. Indian manufacturing sector
The past 5-7 years have seen the Indian manufacturing sector reel under intense competition from China and other countries. Rather than support the manufacturing sector, the economy was opened up to foreign pharma and retail giants. To compound the matters, in several areas foreign companies are given contracts giving Indian concerns a go-by. Empty slogans do not go a long way in boosting investments. For instance, firms in Maharashtra were given raw land without even basic amenities such as roads or electricity.

4. Job creation
 Mr. Modi was not able to deliver on his promise of creating lakhs and lakhs of new jobs as he had promised in his election speeches. To divert public attention from burning issues, this step seems to have been introduced.

5. Basic Infrastructure
Rather than create smart cities and bullet trains, the need of the hour is to create basic infrastructure within the country. The effects and use of allowing free wi-fi  in railway stations is well known. Is this the sort of climate that the Modi government wants to create? Traffic discipline is almost nil in his hometown of Varanasi and he wants to convert it into a smart city?

People would have been more amenable to Mr. Modi's moves had they seen actual changes happening at the ground level.  


Rural neglect and job loss are burning issues around the world including US. At a time like this to neglect genuine concerns is a self-goal the opposition will greatly appreciate. But what the hinterland will gain from all this remains in doubt.

Monday, 14 November 2016

Rail high-fliers bite dust



Stocks such as Kalindee Rail (NSE: KALINDEE), Titagarh Wagons (NSE: TWL), Texmaco Rail (NSE: TEXRAIL), once the high-fliers of the Indian Railway sector have bitten dust. Low-cost competition from Chinese and Spanish firms has forced these companies to enter new lines of business and look for other measures to boost revenues.


These stocks have underperformed the CNX Midcap index an average 35% since Mar 2015. 




Once the favourite of analysts, these stocks do not even find mention nowadays.

The biggest reasons for their fall are the cost-cutting drive initiated by the Indian Railways and the Chinese competition.

In a recent contract awarded by the Nagpur Metro Rail Corp, a Chinese company CRRC was chosen over the Indian manufacturers. At a time when the Prime Minister is touting Make in India, it is a concern that although the Indian manufacturer had outbid CRCC, the contract was awarded to CRCC.

In addition a Spanish company, Talgo, was allowed to make trial runs from Delhi to Mumbai without the permission of the CRS. The Commission of Railway Safety which oversees safety in rail travel and train operations was not even consulted on the trial runs.

This haste to export Indian manufacturing jobs overseas does not augur well for the Indian economy. Job losses and middle class neglect were significant reasons Trump triumphed. Rather than actively promoting job growth within the country, the Railway Minister and the Prime Minister seem to be solely focused on cost-cutting at the expense of quality and passenger safety. A recent project by Talgo in Saudi Arabia ran into trouble and was scrapped.

Mr. Modi would do well to keep the overall interests of the nation in mind and ensure that Indian manufacturing jobs stay within the country.

Friday, 11 November 2016

Adios Dodd-Frank

With the new administration proposing to water down Dodd-Frank, banking stocks have zoomed an impressive 10% over the past two days. Wells Fargo has in fact recovered from the account opening scandals to zoom 13% and is up 7% over the last three months.

What may be good news for the investors may not necessarily be good for the consumers. With significantly watered-down banking and consumer regulations, the average consumer may find himself at the receiving end. With stagnant real wage growth and zooming student loans (above $1 trillion mark), future demand may get significantly affected. Dollar General and Dollar Tree could see substantially increased footfalls. Already Dollar General is up 6.7% over the past two days.

However there may be good news for companies selling luxury goods and services such as Tiffany & Co. (up 6.1%). Cruise liners may be another area to watch out for.

While many Investment Advisors advise a wait and watch policy, the party seems to have already begun for the banks with their WMDs.