Tuesday, 25 October 2016

Tough love: Ratan Tata’s message to Cyrus Mistry and Tata Steel workers and shareholders.



Four years after riding into the sunset, Ratan Tata is back with a message for the incumbent Chairman, Cyrus Mistry and Tata Steel shareholders: “Tough Love”. 

In Happier times
He has succeeded in getting the board of directors to fire Cyrus Mistry barely four years into his job. Cyrus Mistry was at the forefront of efforts to enter into JV with Thyssenkrupp and negotiate pension plans with the UK Government which would have saved thousands of jobs and pensions.

The Chinese onslaught of dumping steel has bled Tata Steel and they have been forced to write off almost $3bn of the $13bn purchase price.  

Ever since Ratan Tata acquired Corus for $13bn at the height of the commodity boom, the business was doomed to fail. Having a write off of nearly $600mn in the very next year of acquisition is certainly an ominous sign. Instead of hiving off the business, Mr. Tata continued with his priced acquisition. Subsequent years saw steel prices crash and alongwith it the high pedestal upon which Mr. Tata placed himself upon. A person of the calibre of Mr. Tata should have been aware that he was riding the very peak of the commodity wave when he bought Corus in a bidding war.


Last 10 years has seen Tata Steel underperforming the BSE Sensex by 140% and giving an absolute return of -18.94%.

Known for his fights against the old guard at the House of Tatas, Mr. Ratan Tata himself has turned old guard. It is anyone’s guess who the new chairman would be accountable to. Most certainly not to the shareholders.

Meanwhile the fate of thousands of workers and investors in Tata Steel hang in balance. Tough love.   

Thursday, 20 October 2016

Blockchain technology: Securities Investors can save atleast $230 million annually.



Blockchain technology has started making significant impacts on financial and non-financial markets worldwide. Right from managing the supply chain in China to handling complex financial applications in New York, the technology is starting to become universally accepted. 

Nasdaq sees blockchain as a “natural fit” for collateral management having already tested the technology on its private markets platform, Linq.


With the basic structure and framework already in place, it may be time to expand this technology to public stock markets. With trade settlement on a real-time basis, it would substantially reduce settlement and systemic risks besides administrative costs. 


A conservative calculation shows that blockchain can save investors atleast $230 million annually. Presently it takes almost 3 days for securities settlement. Both the buyer and seller of the security stand to lose out on the interest in the intervening period. That is 3 days for the buyer and 3 days for the seller totaling 6 days of foregone interest. From the seller’s perspective, he is receiving the money 3 days after and from the buyer’s perspective he is paying the money 3 days earlier than the security exchange. 

In 2015-16 delivered value of securities amounted to $192 bn on NSE and $45 bn on BSE. Considering a 6% opportunity cost of capital (savings rate offered by banks) and a total of 6 days’ settlement cycle, the interest foregone amounts to approx. $230 million annually. 


Apart from the foregone interest, there are several other costs and risks that the buyers and sellers incur. With real time settlement, these costs and risks can be diminished substantially. 


Recently SEBI concluded from its preliminary investigation that several large brokerage houses indulged in fraudulent practices including trading without authority, non-receipts of payouts by clients etc. Blockchain can put an end to these fraudulent practices and bring in much needed transparency in the financial system. 


With real time processing of banking transactions already in place, it is time to move on to real time trade settlements on public stock exchanges.

Wednesday, 19 October 2016

Blockchain technology: Real time trade settlement boon for investors




 
Time was when you had to wait almost a month for your share certificates to arrive by post. With progressive technological advances, that time has come down to 2 to 3 days with the physical certificates replaced by digital records in central depositories. However, the monies or securities need to be tendered beforehand and then the settlement occurs after 2-3 days. The investor loses out on the intervening interest. Some of the brokerage houses, including ICICI securities, have more aggressive practices and deduct the monies or securities a day prior to that stated. 


The blockchain technology promises to revolutionize the existing practices. Alongwith real-time trade settlement, blockchain can cut down on the brokerage charges by eliminating/ reducing middlemen charges. This would be a great boon for traders and investors with immediate settlement of trades at significantly reduced costs.  

At a time when investors are moving more towards index funds, it makes sense for brokerages to adopt newer technologies and slash their charges or risk losing out on the brokerage altogether. What time cannot do competition and technology have done.


ICICI Bank recently concluded a trade finance transaction using a private blockchain technology co-developed with EdgeVerve Systems. Nasdaq has already started experimenting with this system in private trading platforms in 2015. There are numerous instances across the world of successful implementation of this technology. It is time to systematically study and extend the use and benefits of blockchain technology to retail stock trading platforms.