Tuesday, 11 October 2016

Tail wagging the dog?

CLSA on Bharat Forge:

14th July 2016: Sell with a price target of Rs. 655 within one year.
Bharat Forge price: Rs. 727


10th Oct 2016: Buy with a price target of Rs. 1,200 within one year.
Bharat Forge price: Rs. 940

What changed?? Nothing, despite the sell reco the stock went up 25% in the last 3 months. So much for the so-called brokerage recommendations.


Thursday, 6 October 2016

Benjamin Graham on market timing and technical analysis


Small savers subsidize bad decisions taken by banks


Savings passed on by banks

The RBI governor, Dr. Urjit Patel, has given big banks their Diwali gift in advance in the form of a 25 bps rate cut. This move greatly benefits the banks but has negligible and in most cases negative benefits for the small savers.

From 15.01.2015 till 04.10.2016 while the bank rate was cut 200 bps from 8.75% to 6.75%, the banks passed less than half and in most cases less than one-third of the savings to their customers. The table illustrates the transmission of the rate cut savings by banks to their customers. None of the banks have passed on even half, with Kotak and ICICI Bank being the worst performers passing less than one-third the savings.

The common refrain among banks is that their NPA woes don't allow them to pass the savings. But doesn't that amount to small savers subsidizing the bad decisions taken by banks and corporate houses overs the years?

While on the asset side the banks display much reluctance and hesitation to cut rates, they display no such reluctance on the liability side. Banks are able to match up the rate cuts by slashing fixed deposit and term rates for the small savers.

One of the finance companies, Shriram Transport Finance, has enthusiastically applauded the Governor's decision and promptly slashed its fixed deposit rates by 25 bps even though there is no change in its risk profile and financial fundamentals.

It is a sort of double whammy for the small savers in the form of reduced deposit rates and not much benefit on their home or auto loans. This was even admitted by the Governor, but aside from solace he has not much to offer to the small savers.

Wednesday, 5 October 2016

Wells Fargo continues to echo. This time in Indian brokerage houses.



Cross-selling and mis-selling practices just refuse to die in financial institutions. After the Wells Fargo saga, the Indian stock market regulator (SEBI) has found that top Indian brokerage houses indulged in wrongdoings by mis-selling products and opening client accounts without their permission.

Preliminary investigation by SEBI has found that Anand Rathi, Motilal Oswal, IIFL and others opened fake ledger accounts without client knowledge, mis-sold commodity contracts by promising too high returns without delivery and traded without client authority. Such systemic wrongdoing shows brazen disregard for law with the fines considered a minor part of doing business.

US had Congressional hearings. Stumpf had to appear before the Congressional Committee and Wells Fargo has stated that they will claw back $44 million from his compensation. Clinton has pledged to hold Wells Fargo responsible.

There has been no such response from Indian politicians. Wonder what the Indian regulator will come up with? Fine of a few lakh rupees?

Thursday, 29 September 2016

ICICI Prudential Life tanks: Signs of more trouble at ICICI Bank?

 


ICICI Prudential Life had a dismal listing on the exchanges with the stock price down 9.4% so far.

The IPO, one of the biggest after Coal India, saw strong demand from QIB and HNI segments with the QIB segment bidding almost 12 times and the HNI segment bidding 29 times the portion reserved for them. Rakesh Jhunjhunwala placed bids worth Rs. 750 crores.

So what gives after such strong bids being placed and the issue being oversubscribed 10 times?

Part of the reason could be the liquidity crunch at ICICI Bank. The mounting NPA load and the resulting crunch in tiered capital has strained its finances.  The IPO has given it a chance to generate some liquidity.

The 1:8 bid-offer ratio would imply that the selling is by institutional investors. As Prudential didn't sell its stake in the IPO, it seems possible that ICICI Bank is offloading its shares. ICICI Bank wouldn't have been especially keen to sell its stake if it was not under real pressure to do so. The market seems to recognize this and ICICI Bank's shares are down 4.33%.

Tuesday, 23 August 2016

New Season New Story




     
ICICI Securities has just declared a bountiful for the jewellery sector based in part on normal monsoon for India. 

But how legitimate are the claims of ICICI? 

On the same day as the story appeared, there was a small story of a bit of a flood problem in some parts of India. Only that bit part was understated. The flood problem was in half the country and it was a full blown flood fury with the IMD warning that the situation is about to worsen. With several parts of the country receiving deficient rains, including Gujarat one of the biggest spenders, and half the country wrecked by floods it certainly can't be called a normal monsoon other than by the brokerage houses intent on selling their next big story.

Apart from the quantity of rainfall, the timing of rainfall matters substantially. Rains before or much after the sowing season can wreck havoc with the crops and consequently the consumption story.

With the forecast of normal rains in May 2016, brokerage houses, including ICICI, rushed to get their clients interested and consequently invested in the consumption story predicting that good rains would boost consumer demand for consumer durables, two-wheeler and FMCG products. With rains wrecking havoc in half the country, none of the brokerages or fund houses have any explanation to investors stuck in the consumption story. All have conveniently moved on to the next in-thing. 


Time will tell whether the consumption story raked in profits for companies or their investors, but it sure did rake in funds and bonuses at the brokerages and mutual funds. Till then it's time for a new story.

Wednesday, 10 August 2016

Fickle appetites




 
When Shake Shack soared to $52.49 on 30th January, 2015 it was considered somewhat of a revolution and a cult figure. With the Washington Post, even hailing it as the next “new restaurant empire” giving McDonald’s enough reasons to be afraid. 



18 months down the line, it seems the King doesn’t look appetizing enough. With after-hours price of $37.05, SHAK is down almost 29% from its listing high and 60% down from its lifetime high of $92.86. Au contraire, MCD has outperformed SHAK by almost 38% over the past 18 months. 

SHAK's PE of 122 causes investor anguish at a relatively slower growth rate. MCD, on the other hand, with a PE of 22 is relatively immune from such high expectations. 

Like investor preferences, appetites can be quite fickle.


Source: Google Finance